The big question: Have I fallen off a cliff? No.
This morning’s Manhattan Half was a personal worst by 6 minutes. But it served its purposes and, like Ryan Hall in Arizona, I’m not particularly concerned about a sub-par performance. And thanks to Erin C.; someone shouted my name in the fourth mile and I had no idea who it was. But when she appeared in the eighth mile — lying by saying I looked good — I realized it was her. She’s a former and current teammate (and the person who got me into the 2006 NYC Marathon).
Race Report: As noted yesterday, the plan was to go out easy. The course was unusual. Start at about the 26 mile mark of the Marathon and head counterclockwise for 2+ laps, finishing at the 72nd Street Transverse. Fabio had picked up my number, etc., and I met him with time to spare, although things were close because I just missed a subway. First corral, no hassle, no pushing. (Saw Herb C. as we went into the corral, but I lost him as I moved towards the front.)
Horn goes and I don’t know where my head was but it sure wasn’t in Central Park at 8am. Good thing about race no. 1: the need to get mentally accustomed to racing. So I decided to just relax, and came through one at 6:14. (NYRR now has clocks at every mile; given the course, this led to having, e.g., the 13-mile clock about 10 yards after the 7-mile clock about 10 yards after the 1-mile marker.)
Up Cat Hill, with a wave to the cat. 6:28. My that was slow, even with the hill. I wasn’t tired or breathing hard and my form felt smooth. But Oakland-like, there was no there there. So the splits are 6:20, 6:32, 6:31, 6:20 through 6. On the lower loop, my left Achilles tendon suddenly acted up. After about a quarter, I pulled over to the left. (Afterward, Robert told me he passed me here; he ran wonderfully, getting a nice PR.) Try again, still hurt.
Then I decided, what the hell., just go. One of my objectives was to get a qualifier for the NY Marathon and for the NYC Half, and a 1:40 would do that. So I had plenty of time. Plus it’s not good to stop when you can go.
So back in it. I don’t know what the mile 7 split was (I stopped my watch), but that started the final lap. Up Cat Hill again — Hi Cat! — and still running smoothly, if slowly. While I’m generally passing people now, I’m being passed as well. When I’m running well, I don’t get passed in the latter stages of an HM. But I’m concentrating on keeping it smooth. 6:26, 6:19, 6:39 after climbing the Harlem Hills. I was fine going up, but then felt dead at the top. As Cher would say, “Snap out of it.”
Relax and finish. 6:28, 6:18, 6:21, 39. Final numbers: 1:25:28, 193rd O/A, 8th AG, 80.3 AG.
These race reports are inevitably self-indulgent. I haven’t had a decent one in quite a while. From this one, I learn that I can’t call things in. Work must be done, and the two areas lacking are decent mileage (and especially a decent long run) and speed.
Mileage. It’s early days yet, and I’ve begun regular runs with Warren Street on Saturdays. Two weeks ago it was 1:20 when my longest run before that was just an hour. Last Saturday was 1:34, which nearly killed me. A couple of years back when I ran very well, I had a few 2 hour runs in my pocket before I raced, and that’s what I’ll need again. My regular run is up to an hour, a bit over 8. So it’s not a surprise that I fell short today from that perspective.
Speed. I felt fine and smooth. But with only 2 bits of tempo work under my belt, I understand that I’m just not able to generate the turn-over I need to go fast. 6:20 hurts, but I can’t get it down to, say, 6:05.
I know I can get things going again. I’m leaning towards giving the NYC Half a shot, even if it is primo pricey. And I got a time that gets me into that race (and into NYC 2011 if I want to go there). It’s not like I’m at zero. I have a decent, if slight, base for target races in May. Get in the miles, get in the speed. I’ll be fine.

15 comments
Comments feed for this article
January 24, 2010 at 12:21 pm
Robert James Reese
Considering everything, that’s not a bad time at all. I know it’s not what you’re accustomed to, but you were still way closer to the front than the back out there today. To be able to put up that kind of time coming off an injury is very impressive. And, congrats for getting back out there and finishing up instead of throwing in the towel at mile 6. It can’t be easy starting up again, especially at the base of Cat Hill.
January 24, 2010 at 1:47 pm
joegarland
I’d pay good money to have every race start at the base of Cat Hill. And finish at the top. That Cat and I, we have an understanding.
It’s funny. I’m a big guy, but can run up hills quite well.
January 24, 2010 at 1:00 pm
Rick Temerian
I looked for you in the corral- I wanted to introduce myself. I don’t think the conditions were ideal today, a little too much wind and it’s always hard passing people the entire second lap. Finishing with such consistent splits should make you feel good about your training. Look for me at the next points race. Rick Temerian.
January 24, 2010 at 1:44 pm
joegarland
Thanks Rick, I will. But I’m not looking forward to having to do a 5K.
January 24, 2010 at 1:11 pm
Katie
I think you did stupendously. You got your time qualifiers even though you weren’t feeling it; better to go then stop, indeed! I always wave to the cat, too. Happy recovery!
January 24, 2010 at 2:37 pm
nyflygirl
I prefer to flip the bird to the cat
And if this was a “bad day” for you, then can’t wait to see what kinda time you’d put up on a good day-nice job
January 24, 2010 at 4:33 pm
Ari
1:25:28 a bad effort? I can’t even come close to that if I had super human powers. Congrats on a good race. It’s good to see so many great efforts so early in the season.
January 24, 2010 at 5:59 pm
Flo
Wow, you did terrifically!!Sheet, your first race in a while and you pull out a 1:25? You’re going to rip up the road this year, no doubt about it. I’m super impressed with you, Joe. It’s going to be so fun following your adventures this season.
January 24, 2010 at 7:16 pm
AndrewENZ
I aspire to your personal worst!
January 24, 2010 at 7:17 pm
Manhattan Half race report « Law of Inertia
[...] my way over, I saw Joe running and he asked me in German how I was as if I was multiple people, so I answered back in [...]
January 25, 2010 at 5:32 am
Ewen
I have friends just like Erin C — they’re always lying about how good I’m looking.
Sounds like it was a good race to see where you are, and what needs doing. You could do worse than having Cher as a coach.
By the way, what’s Cat Hill? Some hill in Central Park where cats hang out?
January 25, 2010 at 9:53 am
joegarland
Ewen,
Cat Hill is on the east side of Central Park, south of the Metropolitan Museum. It appears just past the 24 mile mark of the marathon but then one goes down; it’s wear Meb crossed himself in 2009 near where Ryan Shay died.
It’s named for the crouching panther statue about half-way up. The hill itself is fairly steep, about 1/4 mile long. According to one source, it’s a 3.7% grade (vs. 4.4% for the Harlem Hill). I’ve done countless repeats up it, and there are many who fear it. After the Harlem Hills, it’s the toughest in the Park, but I love it and always pick off lots of people on it. But whenever I hear of someone “beating” the cat, I counsel caution because the best you can hope for with a hill is a draw. If you think you’ve beaten a hill, it’ll come back and bite you in the ass, perhaps literally in the case of Cat Hill.
January 25, 2010 at 7:33 pm
Alex
Joe–Great race report! I enjoyed reading. Hope that Achilles settles right down. Best, -Alex
January 26, 2010 at 2:23 am
Ewen
Thanks Joe. Hope I get time to look for it when we visit NYC. Sounds a bit like ‘Hospital Hill’ on our old HM course – came at about 16k. Know what you mean about hills biting you on the ass. I have plenty of scars down there.
February 18, 2010 at 7:47 pm
The Third Man « RunWestchester
[...] after a night in which I had far too much to drink at my 25th law school reunion. The recent Manhattan Half and last year’s Scarsdale 15K showing how undertrained I knew I was going in. My first track [...]